Is SEO Worth It for Contractors? Lessons From Reddit

I saw a Reddit discussion about whether SEO services are worth it.  A contractor was asking if $1,750 a month for SEO services was too much. 

There were plenty of Redditors saying it wasn’t worth it. That it was a rip off. Thats typical Reddit.

But whether SEO is worth it depends on what it brings your business…

What Made This Contractor Question Their SEO Investment?

The owner said they were getting decent results but questioned the value of the ongoing work.

They had paid $1,750 a month for the last eight months. They reported roughly 15–20 leads per month, a 30% close rate, and an average job value of $3K.

The concern wasn’t that nothing was happening. They said there had been a lot of initial work. But the ongoing work seemed to consist mostly of blog posts they suspected were written by AI.

“Id like to note that while there was a lot of initial set up from here on out I definitely don’t know how much is truly done.”

— u/NickyD_

Fair question. You need to know what you’re paying for and why it matters.

Is $1,750 a Month for Contractor SEO Worth It?

Paying $1,750 a month for SEO can be worth it if the work brings in enough profitable jobs to justify the cost.

One commenter made a good point:

“I’d judge this on gross profit from organic leads, not revenue.”

— u/TrafficAcademySEO

A $3K job leaves you with less after labor, materials, and other direct costs. And you can’t assume every lead came from SEO.

Another question: How much additional business did the SEO work bring in?

You can’t get a perfect picture of this. But you should have enough info to make a reasonable decision.

How Can You Tell Whether SEO Is Bringing You Business?

Track qualified inquiries from search through to booked jobs. Rankings and traffic help, but they don’t tell the whole story.

Start with a few basic questions:

  • Where are calls and form submissions coming from?
  • Are those people looking for services you actually provide?
  • Are they inside your service area?
  • How many become customers?
  • What are those jobs worth after direct job costs?

Track leads from your website’s organic search traffic, Google Business Profile, paid ads, and referrals. Call tracking, website analytics, and your customer records can help connect those pieces.

Also remember that someone searching your company name may already know you through a referral or another marketing channel.

Qualified inquiries: Are calls and forms coming from people who need your services?
Booked jobs: How many of those inquiries turn into paying customers?
Gross profit: Does the money left after direct job costs justify your SEO spending?
Service page performance: Which service pages generate qualified inquiries and booked jobs?
Rankings and impressions: Are you showing up for searches that can bring in customers?

Look at the data yourself. Seasonal slowdowns and how quickly you respond can affect results too. 

What Should an SEO Provider Be Doing Each Month?

Your SEO should focus on work that supports your business and explain why it matters.

Depending on the business, that could include:

  • Improving your service “money” pages
  • Fixing technical issues
  • Finding opportunities to drive more leads
  • Updating existing content
  • Managing GBP
  • Finding relevant link opportunities
  • Making it easier for visitors to contact you
  • Nailing down which activities produce qualified inquiries

All these tasks don’t need to happen every month. Some months may involve building new pages. Others may focus on updated old ones.

The plan should be specific enough that you understand what’s happening.

Are Blog Posts Enough to Justify Monthly SEO?

Blog posts can be part of SEO work. But blog posts alone aren’t enough to justify $1,750 a month.

Blogs aren’t going to bring in leads. They are useful for topical authority and internal linking. But they’re not going to directly bring in leads.

For a local service business blogs are not a high priority. Especially if it’s going to be AI slop.

Could You Get Similar Results Doing SEO Yourself?

I think a lot of business owners could handle SEO if they the have time. But as a business owner you already have enough to do.  SEO isn’t rocket science but it does take time. 

Another commenter asked:

“The question you have to ask yourself is if your time is worth more or less than $1750?”

— u/Due-Tip-4022

Time matters. So does knowing which tasks deserve it.

As an owner, you can update GBP and site with pictures, ask for honest reveiws and train staff to ask for honest reviews – these are real needle movers for local SEO.

Technical problems, tracking setup, keyword research, and website migrations may require more help.

You also don’t have to limit to monthly service or do everything myself.  

There is always occasional consulting and defined projects. 

What Should You Ask Before Canceling Your SEO Service?

These are good questions to ask before you think about canceling services

  1. Which  leads and booked jobs can be traced to organic search?
  2. What did you change over the last couple months?
  3. Why did you prioritize those changes?
  4. Which pages are producing leads?
  5. What are you planning next, and why?

The answers should help give you a better understanding if monthly SEO is worth it for your goals. 

So, Is Paying for Contractor SEO Worth It?

Yes, SEO can be worth it for contractors. One additional profitable job may cover the monthly fee. The question is whether SEO consistently brings in enough business to justify the cost.

But leads alone can’t settle the question. This particular contractor was getting results but still felt unsure about SEO value.

That’s fair. 

Some SEO agencies charge $2,000 a month for busywork. They cherry-pick data and use it to sell business owners on BS. 

That’s not cool. You should be getting bang for your buck.

If you’re unsure what your current SEO service is doing for your business, get in touch. We can talk through what’s happening and what you want it to accomplish.

Leave a Comment